The BMW B58, an engine which was launched less than a decade ago has already made quite a reputation for itself. From getting hated for being in the Mk5 Supra to taking 'just a downpipe and a tune' game to the completely next level, it has become one of the best modern day engines and also one of the best tuning platforms in the world. Even the best of the tuners from the most capable platforms on the planet like The GTRs, The Hellcats, The Challengers, The Supras, The Lancer Evos, The Golfs, The Skylines, The Corvettes, The Imprezza WRX and STIs, The JDMs or The Germans, The Italians or The Americans, you name it and all the big names from those platforms are now jumping on to the B58 platform, and not without a reason! Stay tuned, as this is one of the most detailed blogs on the internet where we will take a deep dive about the technical details that make the B58 engine so capable, discuss about it's tuning capabilities, why Toyota specifically chose the B58 for it's Mk5 Supra and also compare it to the famed- 2JZ!!
WHY THE COMPARISON THO?
The 2JZ, is one of the most iconic and popular engines in the entire history of automobiles, and has a tuning potential that is so high that it continues to remain the benchmark for tuning even after 30 years! So much so that the 2JZ engines pushing out even 2000 horsepowers doesn't take anyone by suprise anymore. But that engine was on sale 2 decades ago, and if that engine is so damn good then why doesn't Toyota bring it back in some form? Well they did bring the 2JZ back, but this time the 'THEY' weren't Toyota but it was BMW! Well if Toyota can sell rebadged Subarus, Mazdas and even Maruti Suzukis then why not rebadged BMWs? Another rebadged Toyota won't hurt right? When Toyota unveiled the A90 Supra with the BMW's B58 engine, it took the entire internet by storm and the 2JZ fans were basically fuming as to why did Toyota not develop a 3JZ, and instead simply borrow an engine from another automobile manufacturer. This sparked the never ending debate of whether or not is the B58 engine worthy enough to be put into the newer generation of the Supra which was earlier powered by the 2JZ, so let us address that before moving on further.
Why the B58 and not a 3JZ?
So let's address the biggest question as to why Toyota did not themselves develop a 3JZ or some kind of successor to the 2JZ. Sure, the Mk4 Supra went on to be THE TUNER CAR and made quite a name for itself, but the one place it did not do quite well was at- getting sales!, and so was the fate of Toyota's most ambitious project of building it's Ultimate Halo Car : The Lexus LFA! But why did Toyota specifically choose the BMW's B58? Considering the the kind of icon the 2JZ was in the Mk4 Supra, Toyota knew that the only type of engine they could use in the new gen Supra would be an inline 6. However Toyota did not have even a single inline 6 in their product line-up at the time, and given that the Supra is not going to be a mass market product, investing in extensive R&D for one did not make financial sense.
So the next best thing to do would be to borrow one from another brand, and what better option than BMW who have had the longest experience of making inline 6 engines. Toyota decided to have a barter deal with BMW, where BMW would get to have their hands on Toyota's hydrogen cell technology to implement in their X5, and Toyota would get to do their most favourite thing ever: Slapping on a Toyota logo on cars which aren't theirs. Toyota then even went on to use the entire BMW Z4 platform for which they had to modify their gorgeous FT1 concept car for their new Supra around the Z4's hardpoints, and that is how the A90 Supra (Mk5) basically became a rebadged BMW Z4

What makes the B58 platform so good

Comparing the mechanicals of the B58 vs 2JZ:
There have been a few iterations of the 2JZ, like the 2JZ-GE, 2JZ-GTE and also the VVTi variants of both, but for the sake of this comparison we will be considering the best and most popular variant in terms of tuning, which is the 2JZ-GTE (non-VVTi) having a sequential twin turbo setup.
The similarities:
The differences:
Since we are already here, the S58 which is the bigger sibling of the B58 has a few more similarities with the 2JZ, like it's twin 'mono scroll' turbo setup, and is one more step closer to the 2JZ with it's close to square setup with a 90mm stroke and 82mm bore and relatively lowered compression ratio of 9:3:1, plus the forged pistons.
Tuning a B58 vs a 2JZ:
2JZ:
The 2JZ make 286 horses in the Japanese market and above 300 horses in the overseas markets, and could be easily made to make 330-350 horses without any mechanical changes and about 400hp with just simple bolt-on mods. And for any of those 12 year olds who think that the 2JZ can do 2000hp, 3000hp and even 5000hp on the stock engine, NO IT CAN'T!! The fastest that a 2JZ has done on stock internals is somewhere around 1100hp and it basically lasted only for a few runs and the stock cast iron block starts getting to its limits around the 1500+hp mark, beyond which it starts requiring an upgrade to a billet aluminum block. Even the stock internals are good enough untill the 800hp mark and pushing them any further is basically just a matter of time untill something will give up on you.
Also, you would need to upgrade a dozen of things like extensive fueling upgrades, ditching the twin turbo setup for a big single turbo, aftermarket ECUs, cooling upgrades like aftermarket radiator and intercooler, aftermarket camshafts, better valve springs, porting your cylinder heads, free flow exhaust with an aftermarket intake and things like that to get to the 800hp mark, while on the B58 you can get to the same horsepower figures with simple bolt-on mods like an upgraded heat exchanger, upgraded high pressure fuel pump (HPFP), an aftermarket intake manifold, a decat downpipe and a bigger turbo, without needing to upgrade your stock ECUs, stock cams or porting your cylinder heads. Not only will the 2JZ require more work to reach to the 700-800hp mark, but it will also not be as good of a daily driver like the B58 as it will not have the relentless low-end torque, fuel economy, smooth power delivery and overall NVH levels and driving experience like the stock engine B58.
However credit where it is due, the 2JZ definitely deserves appreciation for being a much simpler and more tried and tested engine than the B58, for not having the added complexities like the oil pump on the B58, it's Double Vanos and Valevtronic systems, and by placing the timing chain behind the engine right near the transmission housing. Also, the 2JZ has been around for almost 30 years at this point, and has been thoroughly tested across all applications. Not only does the 2JZ have a whole load of aftermarket support, tuners from all over the world have already extracted every bit of power from the engine and have tested the limits of all the mechanicals of the 2JZ, hence there is next to nothing that you can go wrong with a 2JZ build.
The B58:
Similarly to the 2JZ, the B58 engines also make more power when tested on independent dynos, for example: The gen2 B58 in the m340i was rated at 382-387 hp doing 0-100 in 4.4 secs but the car was seen to be making close to almost 400 horses and could do 0-100 in 4.2 secs! Just a simple engine remap with zero modifications could take it to 430-450 horses depending on it's fueling quality, and could do slightly over 500 hp on stock turbos with a decat downpipe, upgraded fueling in case you are running a gen1 B58, an aftermarket intake and some cooling mods. Pair it with some high ethanol mix and WMI and the engine could do even upwards of 550hp and 950nm of torque !! Mk5 Supras with the same configuration and racing slicks are already in the 9sec quarter mile thanks to their smaller and lighter form factor, while the m340is manages to do 10sec runs.
Once you start slapping on bigger turbos and cross the 600hp mark, you will have to slightly limit the torque at lower revs and even in the higher gears, as the gearbox starts to slip quite a bit and needs to be rebuilt with upgraded internals if you want to ensure the gearbox works and shifts properly. Once that is out of the way, the stock engine is good upto 700hp and max upto 800hp, beyond which you are risking to have bent rods, failed piston rings or a damaged piston. Once you have adressed that, going upwards of even 1000hp is not a big deal for the B58, and once you start building these engines there is no looking back. Some tuners abroad who are risking it all to test out the capabilities of the stock engine B58s have pushed them to more than 1000hp and even slightly more, m240is with stock engines and built transmissions have managed to do a mid 8 secs quarter mile. Infact, the fastest BMW on the planet is a completely built drag spec m240i with a 3.2 litres stroker engine setup and loads of upgraded drivetrain and powertrain parts produces 1500hp and does a quarter mile in the 7 secs range!! The same goes with the S58 which is THE BEST inline 6 on the market, and is obviously even more capable than the B58 but is also more expensive. The S58 too shows incredible amounts of power gains again with a couple of bolt-on mods and is capable of handling upto 1000hp and running mid 8 secs quarter mile with upgraded turbos on stock internals, and built engine S58s have already made their way into the low 8 secs and are ready to break-in into the 7 secs range!
There's actually more than just the peak power figures or quarter mile times. Have a look below to see how the B58 makes insane amounts of power with both the stock turbo and an aftermarket hybrid turbo at different engine RPMs, when compared to the stock configuration.

As you can see, the stock turbo engine makes a healthy amount of extra power right from the lower revs which starts to narrow down once the engine climbs up to higher revs. This is because although the stock turbo spools really quick, it basically starts to run out of steam post 6k RPMs as it is meant to focus on maximising low end performance and minimising turbo lag, instead of top end performance. The engine with upgraded turbos however makes lesser power at lower revs when compared to the stock engine and even introduces some turbo lag to the engine which has almost instantaneous throttle response, since the bigger turbo doesn't get fully spooled at the lower RPMs. But once the bigger turbo kicks-in, it produces loads of extra power and torque and just keeps pulling till the redline, since the boost doesn't die down like the stock turbo does.
Take-away:
It would be a bit to early to declare whether or not will the B58 (and S58) be able to dethrone the legendary 2JZ, and that is something only time can answer. But what we definitely know as of now is that the B58 seems to be extremely promising, and the B58 community has already proved this by setting new records at almost every drag race event. The B58 has already achieved in less than a decade what the 2JZ took almost 3 decades to achieve, thanks to the rigorous R&D and ever evolving aftermarket support for the B58 by all the major tuning firms in terms of hardware and software upgrades.
Considering the ever stringent emission norms and global regulations, the B58 is probably THE BEST that a modern tuner engine can get, and is definitely worthy enough to be the termed as the successor to the 2JZ! And regardless of what the internet might say, the B58 is the modern day 2JZ and a FUTURE ICON IN THE MAKING!! However, there is even more to just this in the BMW's B58 and we have a detailed blog covering the technical specifications of all the different variants of the B58 and why it is currently the best engine on sale in India! You can read it by clicking HERE
If you enjoyed reading this, then you can read more of such insightful articles on our website, or you could also head to our YouTube channel for unbiased and informative automobile content. You can also avail paid consultancy by Munish Ji for expert guidance on any car related queries, and we also have some genuine used car deals listed on our website. A huge thanks to everyone of you for your precious time!
Shared by: Akshay Kashyap
